Article body copy

West Africa’s artisanal fishing fleet has grown in size and engine power to the point where it now dwarfs the region’s industrial fleet. Yet despite a massive labor force and steadily growing horsepower, artisanal fishers still catch way less fish.

Over the past 65 years, the total artisanal fishing effort in the coastal waters from Morocco to Namibia has increased 10-fold. Thousands of people in West Africa work as artisanal fishers, providing fish for their local communities. Yet over time, and in contrast to their industrial counterparts, artisanal fishers have become less efficient. That is the finding of a seven-year study by experts with the University of British Columbia’s Sea Around Us project.

The results paint a picture of West Africa’s subsistence fishers as a rapidly expanding group of people who are working in increasingly difficult conditions.

Illustration by Mark Garrison

The team developed a new assessment metric—a way of assessing fishing effort—that let them directly compare the successes of the artisanal and industrial fishing fleets. The researchers compiled data on the number of boats operating in the region, their size, the number of days they operate, and the type of gear they used. When a boat wasn’t motorized, manpower was converted into energy. Compiling this with the size of the fishing catch gave the scientists a standard measure: how many fish are caught per unit of energy spent.

In the 1950s, the scientists report, there were 750,000 artisanal fishers operating 50,000 boats to catch 540,000 tonnes of fish each year. The industrial sector had, in the same period, 37,150 fishers operating 500 boats with a catch of 1.1 million tonnes of fish.

By the turn of the century, artisanal fishers’ boats had grown in size and capacity. Local fish stocks were declining because of over-exploitation by foreign industrial fishers, and the displacement of fish caused by warming waters. Artisanal fishers were forced to adapt.

The researchers tracked how much energy is needed to catch a fish—whether that’s the horsepower of a fishing boat motor, or the effort of a person casting a net. They found that while industrial fishing is becoming more efficient, artisanal fishers are having to spend more energy to catch fish than they used to. Illustration by Mark Garrison

As the researchers note, some artisanal fishers’ boats can now be up to 30 meters long. They’ll carry 40 fishermen, and can stay at sea for up to 10 days.

“Fishers have to go further, and hence have boats that can stay at sea for longer. However, they catch less fish,” says Dyhia Belhabib, who led the team at Sea Around Us.

In the 2000s, the most recent period for which data was available, there were 3.5 million artisanal fishers using 225,000 boats to harvest 1.6 million tonnes of fish. In the industrial fleet, 3,300 boats operated by 24,519 fishers were pulling in 4.1 million tonnes of fish.

In some parts of West Africa, Belhabib says, the uncontrolled growth of the artisanal fleet is putting unsustainable pressure on fish populations. At the same time, competition with foreign fleets—particularly illegal ones—is increasingly fierce.

There are “too many fishers chasing too few fish,” she says.

In the 2000s, there were more than five times as many artisanal fishers in West Africa as there were in the 1950s. Photo by Tommy Trenchard/Alamy Stock Photo

The net result is fish populations that are declining dangerously—losses that threaten the livelihoods and food security of small-scale fishing communities. But it’s important to step back and pose the bigger question: why, asks Belhabib, is there such a drastic increase in the number of artisanal fishers but such a dramatic decrease in their fishing efficiency?

Djiga Thiao, a research director with the Oceanographic Research Center Dakar-Thiaroye, in Senegal, says more should be done to reduce the pressure on fish stocks.

The focus should be on fishing efficiency, while promoting equal access to fishing resources and national food security, says Thiao.

Unlike industrial fishers, for all their effort, artisanal fishers’ effects on the ecosystem are relatively benign. Belhabib says future policy should focus on helping artisanal fishers sustainably improve their catches.

“If it takes a reduction in the industrial fishing effort, particularly of foreign ownership, then this should be prioritized,” Belhabib says.

Keen to see fisheries science informing fisheries governance, Shehu Akintola, a fisheries expert from Lagos State University in Nigeria says it’s always a challenge for African countries to move from research to policy implementation.

“Walking our talk remains the critical challenge to such studies benefitting the fishers in West Africa,” Akintola adds.